Additional Information:
This nomination was incorrectly declined by the automated AI filter, which hallucinated the submission as a generic natural rock or terrain feature.
It is actually an authentic, hand-carved sandstone bird bath sculpture created by prominent local sculptor May Barrie, donated by the Beale family in memory of Mrs. Robertson. It sits permanently along the walking trail at the Illawarra Rhododendron & Rainforest Gardens alongside an official educational plaque detailing its history.
In this circumstance, the process would be to use an appeal.
We don’t know precisely what triggers the machine learning tool to automatically reject submissions, but one of the common factors is ‘too much plant-life’.
If the appeal doesn’t work out, I would resubmit with a photo that was more centred on the object / with more of the surrounding plants cropped out.
If you don’t have the option to appeal there, you may not have an appeal to use. We get two appeals, each on a 15 day counter before we can use them again.
If you would rather resubmit, a cropped photo making the art piece the center of the photo may help. I would try taking a couple of steps back so you don’t cut off the sides of the piece, then cropping to square. It can help make it clearer that you aren’t just submitting a random spot in a forest. I can’t really show exactly what I mean, but something like this:
Yesterday I submitted 12 Wayspots, and just now I’ve had 10 of them rejected by the AI. Honestly, I’m pretty frustrated and disappointed with the results. These weren’t ridiculous or borderline submissions either. They included a swimming pool at a local beach, a couple of signs, a historic park and two sculptures.
I’m struggling to understand how these are being knocked back. I understand not every submission is going to be accepted, but rejecting 10 out of 12, especially when they are genuine places of interest, is pretty disappointing. It makes you wonder what the AI is actually looking for. Surely some of these deserve a proper review rather than being automatically rejected.
Nope none left too many rejected by AI.
honestly think if you submit an appeal, it gets reviewed and your Wayspot is accepted, you should get that appeal back.
If the original rejection was wrong and the appeal proves your submission was eligible, why should you lose an appeal for correcting a mistake made by the system? Appeals are limited, and they shouldn’t be wasted fixing incorrect AI decisions.
It would be a fair way to reward accurate appeals and encourage people to challenge rejections when they genuinely believe their submissions meet the criteria.
Please check this list of common reasons for rejection, as it might explain some of these. The ML filter does not just check the photo.
In order to be accepted, a wayspot has to not fail any of the rejection criteria
- it has to be safely accessible to pedestrians
- it can’t be on school grounds, single-family private residential property, farmland
- it has to exist at the location given
- it has to have a reasonably accurate title and description
- the photo cannot contain licence plates, identifiable people, unnecessary animals
- it cannot represent something that already has a wayspot
- the photo must be one that you took and have not posted elsewhere
- it has to be reasonably distinct, not just a random location
It also has to meet one of the key criteria
- Exploration
- Exercise
- Social
Something can meet the key criteria but be rejected because it fails one of the rejection tests.
Something can pass all the rejection reasons but still not be eligible because it simply isn’t meeting criteria.