Complaint abour rejecyed appeal ..... again

Yep, another complaint, this time though I think its valid

They say they can confirm the location and to take extra pictures, but I did

And to even make sure, i mentioned that the trees beside it, which can be seen from multiple pictures are visible on google maps

the worst bit is, it was rejected as a duplicate as theres a similar installation nearby, so even if i resubmit it, it will be marked as duplicate again as the picture will show up.

Basically, end of the rant, the appeal reviews need to try a bit more

IMO, the problem isn’t that they cant tell if it exists within its surroundings – it certainly does – but if those surroundings (and therefore the POI) are at that location. Satellite imagery from 18 months ago says there’s nothing there, Streetview cant see anything from any of the surrounding streets looking in, there’s no local council or news reports (that I could find with a quick search from the other side of the globe) about the new installations.

If you could get supporting photos that anchor to another distinctly verifiable location (not a large tree that could plausibly match) and your submission, or something from a 3rd party, that would help a lot. Rockworks Climbing Walls may have been the creator of the installations, maybe you can see if they can confirm that, or add it to their website portfolio.
Example:


I will say its odd, but not uncommon that your other submission went through and this one didn’t, and IMO it shouldn’t’ve been marked as duplicate.

I would agree if it was just the one tree, but theres also shots of houses of the street, so can be lined up with them, maybe not exact, but close enough

Honestly i cant see anything from the satelite? Are you sure its visible? I see bench from your surrounding foto but i cant match it with the object as well

Hi

Is there any articles about these new installations and the work done to convert this space?

It is a real pain trying to get things that are new when satellite and streetview are not going to help.

In the background of supplementary 4/5 I can make out a distinctive house - it’s not clear on your screen shot maybe better on the full photo?

I would try and get a different sequence of images to use in the supplementary

You could have one on the spot with location watermarked eg GPSmapcamera

Then a sequence walking the reviewer from streetview to the site as it were.

That way they can make the link between a clear point on streetview to the location maybe a few weeks from now when the foliage has thinned out / gone will make that easier?

Seemingly not. I’ve had a look online and can’t see anything, which is a shame, because I don’t think Glasgow City Council have that many positive things going on in Milton :sweat_smile:

As Gazza knows, I’m moderately familiar with the area, but I’m honestly at a loss as to how he can prove the location other than via a video… Could you take a vid, upload to YouTube and then link to it in the additional text section? Massive faff, but it would be fairly incontrovertible.

Yeah, wven when it was first decided there was nothing on the council’s website, it was just a random sign on a tree lmao