I would like some help with a potential nomination. Hoping to get some tips on getting this at least through to queue/voting so it doesn’t get rejected by the AI.
I can provide pictures that I have taken myself, but not sure if it will then be classed as third party if I reupload when nominating.
This is what I want to nominate:
" Shah’s
A prominent local destination specialising in Islamic modesty wear, traditional garments, and regional food. Beyond its retail offering, the shop serves as a vital cultural touchstone and welcoming fixture for the neighborhood’s diverse community.
This location fulfills the Niantic criteria for Exploration and Socialisation. It is not a generic commercial chain; it is a hyper-local, independent business that provides an essential cultural resource for the local Muslim community. It acts as an important neighborhood meeting point, fostering community integration.
The inclusion of an outdoor picnic bench that seats upto 6-8 people creates a welcoming neighborhood meeting point where residents regularly gather and socialise. This is a great pit-stop enroute to Wardown Park and Blundell Road Recreation Ground.
Safe pedestrian access is fully available via the large public footpath and pavement."
P.s. I have an upgrade available so could potentially use that.
P.s.s. street view of this place is severely outdated. Could this affect my chances?
Staff have said that photos posted here will not be considered 3rd party. However posting them to a site like reddit or Google Maps could get the 3rd party flag, so you are wise to be careful.
I am having trouble understanding how this is not just a “Generic business,” which is a rejection reason, even if it does offer culturally important items. If you could go into the uniqueness and importance of the place, that might convince. For example, if it is the only place to procure these items, or if events are held there.
The table in front of it does sound like a place to gather and be social. You might focus on that.
We don’t know exactly what the machine learning model checks for. I always expect it to struggle to find something eligible with a less common submission. Even if the “automated process” rejects a nomination, you can still use an appeal on it to get human staff to review it. We get two appeals, each on a 15 day counter before we can use it again.
Concentrate on the food, and prove that there is a sit-down area.
Even so, I don’t especially rate your chances of getting this accepted.
I did manage to get a kosher deli / cafe through, but had the ace of “this is the only deli of its kind in Scotland”. I don’t think you will be able to add anything with quite that impact, as Islamic shops are far more common.
Out of date streetview is an issue, so once you are aware of it, you can rectify this. Use the 5 supporting photos to show that your POI does exist, from multiple angles and distances.
Only the picnic bench makes this potentially eligible as a point of socialisation, so focus on that. Nothing else is helping with eligibility. Certainly not being a pit-stop en-route to other places.
Would it better then to come at it as a picnic area outside of a unique dual-concept store? A place for socialisation where people can also buy cultural attire and food.
No, the burger shop doesn’t own it.
(Also, I don’t think the burger shop is even a real shop. It never opens and I have never seen customers go in or out. ahemlaundryahem)