My Poketop was removed from in game, please re-instate it

When submitting a Wayspot Appeal, make sure to include as much of the following information as possible:

  • Wayspot Title: Sandalwood Heights Sports Field

  • Location (lat/lon): around coordinates 43.765137, -79.741940

  • City: Brampton

  • Country: Canada

  • Screenshot of the Rejection Email (do not include your personal information): - no rejection email, pokestop was approved, appeared in game then disappeared.

  • Additional Information (if any): I am requesting a review of the removal of the wayspot formally titled “Sandalwood Heights Sports Field” in Brampton, Ontario. The wayspot was originally titled “Sandalwood Heights Sports Field”. I acknowledge that this title was incorrect. The physical location I nominated was the soccer field as Torbram Sandalwood community park. The soccer field is located within the track at the park. It is a municipal parks sports field and is not part of the adjacent school property. The wayspot was accepted, appeared in Pokemon Go, and was physcially present in the game before it disappeared. This occurred more than a year ago and I did not receive a removal notification, so I do not know if it was removed following a repot or another reason. The soccer field still exists at the same location, I would like to request Scopely review the wayspot and determine why it was removed. If removed in error, I respectfully request that it be restored. I also understand the original title was incorrect. If the wayspot is restore, an accurate description should be “Torbram Sandalwood Community Park Soccer Field #4” as it would better identify the location. Here is the link to Brampton’s park directory which shows there is 1 cricket pitch, 4 soccer fields and 1 track. [Parks Directory - PRD]

  • (Experience)

Hello and Welcome,

Open Street Map does show this has part of the School Grounds (everything within the yellow background).

School Property rejections have been seen for Property belonging to the School, Authority owned property used solely or majority by the school (such as where the school has sole use during school hours but others can book the use at other times).

If this is not the case here this is the evidence that you will need to supply to staff.

Good Luck

Hello and thank you for your response and thank you for looking into this! I never heard of open street maps and was going off the Brampton Parks Directory which doesn’t state that this is school properly but rather apart of Torbram Sandalwood Community Park, but thank you for investigating and explaining why it was not eligible.

Regards,
Vickey

Open Street Maps can be wrong since it is created by users, not official government sources. So I was looking around for any evidence that you could present that the field is not on school property, but instead I found evidence from signs on street view that the whole Torbram - Sandalwood Cricket Ground is on school property and those should be removed, too.

I am not going to file a report since I am unfamiliar with Canadian traffic signage, but don’t be surprised if everything in the area is removed.

Please note that staff who can officially decide this appeal will have user names here beginning with “ScopelyExp” and the rest of us are just fellow wayfinders.

I do usually mention this but I do find it a good place to start.

Pokemon Go also uses OSM for Biomes etc so they are not totally against using it.

Yep, it just helped a lot with doing a report of a dozen wayspots on a K-12 campus, but I also used other information. Most people who contribute to OSM are extremely concerned about accuracy. Except the ones trying to create Wiglett biomes.

Hi Cyndiepooh,

I believe there may be a misunderstanding here. Sandalwood Cricket Ground is located within Torbram Sandalwood Community Park, not on school property. This is separate from the issue I originally posted about regarding my PokéStop disappearing.

The cricket pitch is listed as a bookable facility, with bookings available through the cricket pitch’s website from 7:00 AM to 8:00 PM on weekdays and weekends. Other park facilities can also be booked through the city.

Please take a look at the link before concluding that the locations are on school property. I believe the available information supports that these are legitimate park facilities, and I would appreciate keeping the discussion focused on the actual issue I raised.

Here is the official City of Brampton Link to book the cricket pitch.

Torbram/Sandalwood Cricket

City of Brampton | Recreation | Cricket Pitch Bookings

Returning to the original issue of my PokéStop disappearing, the location in question was within the track. As I previously explained, I provided an official City of Brampton link confirming that all 4 soccer fields and the track are part of Torbram Sandalwood Community Park.

I am providing the official City of Brampton parks directory link once again (official government documentation), which lists all four soccer fields, along with the cricket pitch, as part of Torbram Sandalwood Community Park.

I would appreciate it if we could focus on the original issue and refer to the official city documentation rather than making assumptions about everything else being on school property.

Parks Directory - PRD

I’m not familiar enough with your side of the world to go digging through land ownership, so I have no idea if this is school property or not, but please be aware that just because a facility can be booked out does not mean that it is conclusively not school property.

Plenty of schools have facilities that they rent out to bring in more funds. This does not make them eligible, nor would it likely be accepted as proof by Scopely staff.

Not if the stop was removed because it was reported as being school property and Scopely staff agreed, which is the most probable chain of events.

I was just indicating what the situation looks like to me as another wayfinder, not as anyone official, to explain what you may need to overcome for this appeal. I made clear that I am not staff. Staff will evaluate your evidence and decide for themselves. If the Wayspot has been removed, they will either have evidence that it should have been removed, or had a request from the property owner to remove it.

Your link does clearly show the track is part of the community park, but does not show that the park is not on school property.


My city often puts community facilities on school property to double up on the parking space.

The Google label indicates that the soccer fields are on school property. You can submit an edit to that if it is incorrect.

The signs I was referring to are the ones at the entrance to the soccer fields that seem to me to be indicating you are entering the school.

Possibly you could find other signs that are not visible on street view that indicate that this park is not part of the school property to help your case for reinstatement.

There is also a “School Boundaries” tab on the school website that could possibly help your case, but it comes up blank for me. School Boundaries - Sandalwood Heights Secondary School
Possibly you would have access to use it?

Good luck with your appeal.

Google Maps often uses official government sources. I would not be surprised if OSM is also plugged in in some way (though maybe not as completely).

OpenStreetMap is a free, editable map of the whole world made by people like you. It was started in 2004 in the UK, out of frustration with the lack of availability of good map data that was free to use.

OpenStreetMap includes data about roads, buildings, addresses, shops and businesses, points of interest, railways, trails, transit, land use and natural features, and much more.

The map is created and maintained by nearly 5 million registered users and more than 1 million map contributors in every country in the world, using free tools and software. The data is used by local people, volunteer groups, companies, governments, software developers and more.

The project has a very lean governance structure, run entirely by the volunteers of the OpenStreetMap Foundation. Financial support comes from the OpenStreetMap Foundation members, including corporate members, as well as donations.

I don’t know why people get so upset when I say that it isn’t an official source. It can be a valuable tool, but for the purposes of a Wayspot appeal, it isn’t the final word on the facts on the ground there. The OP had taken the statement that OSM was showing this as a school to be incontrovertible, and I was simply bringing up that there could be other evidence to contradict the coding here.

However, it does appear as far as I can tell that the track area is part of the school as it shows. And possibly the rest of the park. I won’t reply on this topic any more.

Thank you, I would appreciate that. I would also like to point out that the Google Street View imagery is completely outdated and does not accurately reflect what the area looks like today. It is not a live or current view, so I would appreciate it if we can leave my post solely up to Scopely to review and respond to.

A lot of governments are putting data online. I’ve found the the search “city admin_area_level1 gis map” (where admin_area_level1 is something like state, province, etc), will often find a hit.

Doing a search for [brampton ontario gis map] I found Bramptons Geohub

After poking around on that, I followed Apps → MyBrampton and ended up at MyBrampton PRD

The search feature on that was not useful, but scrolling around, I found this:

My apologies. I did not mean to come off as upset.

I was meaning to suggest that OSM may also be ingesting some official sources as well.

Thanks for the appeal, @vbunny5! We have taken another look but stand by our decision to retire this Wayspot.