No reason behind the rejection

Hello there everyone!

I was wondering if any of you have got this type of rejection before:

As you can see there is no reason for the rejection leaving me a little confused. Usually it says anything from it’s “not permanent or distinct”, or no pedestrian access, but here there’s nothing. It’s been like this for a few days now, as I was thinking this could be a glitch. It’s been through a vote so no automatic rejection. I’m probably going to appeal it anyway because I’ve nominated many “welcome” place signs before and until this one they’ve all been accepted. Although those were nominated through the previous nomination system.

Hello and welcome @DanzDanzoo

First have you logged out and in?

Can I clarify what this is please?

It looks as though it is a housing estate diagram?

Is that correct?

Thanks a lot for the welcome!

I’ve logged out and in many times now, but still no changes.

The nomination is a welcome sign useful for arriving guests locals etc, which showcases the entire public area like a map. It’s located on a grassy lane in quiet urban surroundings, and is the only one made for this neighbourhood.

I have another pokestop nomination with the exact same issue. The other 8 pokestops I nominated which were rejected in the same wave as the previously mentioned ones were rejected through normal channels.

That is odd that nothing is showing. The wayfarer Team may be able to respond.

Unfortunately this sort of sign is rarely eligible/acceptable.

It may have limited value to someone looking which way to go so it’s a more elaborate way of getting direction, and over a small area.

You may see some of these as accepted but often they accepted wrongly.

So like many things in Wayfarer it is not a simple yes or no as it will vary depending on what is on the sign, so occasionally some may be deemed good enough.

If you are going to appeal I would work on the assumption that it has not been considered special enough - so has been rejected as not distinct.

If there is any question about safe pedestrian access then that needs to be addressed.

If you could provide the co ordinates we could advise.

Make sure your appeal is honest about what it is

Do you have any play spaces in the estate?

Or do any of the footpaths lead to longer walking trails that someone can explore or exercise?

I have also had this response before. It’s rare, but does happen, and in my experience it stays that way. I’m afraid I have no idea what the trigger is – my best guess is that it happens when there isn’t one clear reason why the sub was rejected, but that’s just a guess.

In case it helps at all, here is the last one that had it:

(And yes, I know it’s not a particularly strong sub, no need for advice! :smiley: )

Good to know I’m not the only one with this issue:)

Thanks for the response and advice:)

The neighbourhood has multiple playgrounds, benches, hangout spots, gravel football pitches and basketball hoops. It’s a quiet neighbourhood which is publicly accessible. The sign is standing on a grassy spot which has safe pedestrian access.

This should be the location:

https://maps.app.goo.gl/MXbSrvSny5ebtk5n9?g_st=ic

The other pokestop with the same rejection issue is right across the road.

It can happen when its rejected for multiple reasons. I recall it happen before but i cant find the post

Edit

Found it.

I presume it is not what you want to hear but I Suspect reviewers basically do not find these acceptable and have a number of reasons that they are using to reject. So it’s frustrating as you are not getting a clear message to reflect on why it’s rejected. But my advice then is that this is failing on different reasons so that indicates that it is not suitable generally, not meeting basic criteria.

It’s great that you have had play areas in the estate so you do have some wayspots. I would let these go.

Hi and welcome! I would also suggest focusing on other things in the neighborhood, as this map doesn’t look to me like it meets criteria.

Thanks again for the answers:)

I’ll still try my luck I think. I think I can make a compelling argument like I did with the other ones I appealed and won. You guys have taught me a lot today, so thank you very much for your advice.

Hope you guys have a great day (or night depending on where you are). You deserve that!