Photos that violate the rules are highly popular among Pikmin Bloom players

coordinate: 38.041013, 140.531262

Mod note: please no callouts by username, thank you.

As shown in the attached images, a large number of Pikmin players have been spamming “likes” within a short period to change the cover photos to ones that violate the rules. Although these photos are typically removed three days after being reported, the cycle repeats every time a removal occurs. It remains unclear whether Wayfarer officials can also penalize the accounts that “liked” these non-compliant photos.

This is ridiculous for this photo to have even been accepted, much less to have 100+ likes. Agree having to report this photo to help chat for removal is not the solution if this is happening often. I wonder if the people who thumbed this will also be investigated when it is reported? Maybe mention that in the report?

In my view, there is a systemic reason why this behavior persists: photos are not actually removed from the database even after being taken down. Instead, this actually makes players more eager to obtain these “limited-time” postcards.

I believe that when a photo is removed for violating Wayfarer guidelines, it should simultaneously be deleted from the database used by the game; only then can the incentive for such abuse be completely eliminated.

I don’t think this is accurate.

[Edit: OH! you mean in Pikmin Bloom, it stays. Oof!]

You are saying Pikmin Bloom does not sync photo removals?

Yes! When Pikmin Bloom obtains a postcard, it stores the image URL. Therefore, even if the photo is removed from Wayfarer, it will still remain in your postcard album; removing it from Wayfarer only ensures that it cannot be obtained again.

I suggest that when Wayfarer processes the removal of a photo, it should simultaneously set the photo’s URL to private or invalidate it.

Yeah, there are people that gloat on Reddit about having their dogs in pictures. :roll_eyes:

It was mentioned on the Wayfarer Discussion Discord that this is a third party photo as well.
https://maps.app.goo.gl/bC6hz8ptQXbMosyV8

Given that people can like a photo from within a game without ever touching Wayfarer, or coming into contact with the Wayfarer rules, I don’t think it would be fair to penalise the ‘likers’.

Incidentally, does anyone know the reasoning behind the ‘no animals’ rule? I can’t quite get my head around what negative consequences such a photo could have for Scopely / originally have had for Niantic.

I’m following the topic as I had not known about this issue.

As far as animals being in a picture there are a few reasons it’s not wanted. First focusing or including an animal could obscure the photo representation of the actual Wayspot. Secondly, nominators could use their pet as a form of signature to influence local reviewers.

Plus an animal does not fulfill the requirement for a Wayspot photo to be

  • Of the actual permanent physical, tangible, identifiable object or place marker for an area

And it meets the rejection criteria of

But they can be sent educational emails.

A nearby wayspot has photos with animals in it as well. But those photos were added 9 and 11 years ago.

Correct.

Even if the official team receives reports and removes photos violating the rules, these photos will still remain in the game — ironically, this leads some Pikmin players to believe they are “limited edition” or “rare” postcards.

If the Scopely/Wayfarer Team doesn’t change this rule, these players will continue to upload violating photos, such as those featuring fake landscapes, animals, AI-generated rainbows, or aurora borealis, and will rush to change wayspot photos (by likes) before the system update, even if it’s only for a day or two.

Indeed, they’ve even created “wayspot like groups”, thanking the new Wayfarer website’s function!

I can appreciate the ‘obscuring’ issue, though I would mark that down as a poor quality photo. Hadn’t considered the pet angle, though yes, you do get the ‘here is my dog’ photos from time to time.

I still probably wouldn’t reject an image that contained a wild animal if it didn’t detract from the photo subject though.

(To be clear that is very much not the case in the fox photo here!)

Images appear to be gone.

Then you’ve got people bragging about getting their dog into the game like this: https://www.facebook.com/share/p/18rR2f7hB5/?mibextid=wwXIfr

I’m out of reports for the day but here are the coordinates: 51.187106,4.837469

:man_facepalming:t2:

Staff are reluctant to remove photos unless there is another to take it’s place.

To get these removed someone local needs to add a new photo then report the current 1 through Help Chat.

Unfortunately I am approx 300 miles away (and that includes a swim).