Pokestop with no public access?

When submitting a Wayspot Appeal, make sure to include as much of the following information as possible:

  • Wayspot Title: Mosaico de la Virgen María y el Niños Jesús.
  • Location (lat/lon): -2.163566,-79.903615
  • City: Guayaquil
  • Country: Ecuador
  • Screenshot of the Rejection Email:
  • Additional Information (if any):

Hello.

I want to appeal this personaly because it actually fulfills the requirements to be a wayspot.

  1. Significance
    Guayaquil, Ecuador is a Cristhian/Catholic country. Images of religious background are treasured by the comunity.

  2. Resemblance to other local stops and other countries.

“Grutas de la Virgen” are Waystops in Guayaquil-Ecuador that are recurrent, also in México there’s a lot of Wayspots about the “Virgen” that are located outside houses but have street access.

  1. Public Acess

This spot is actually in the outside wall of a house, just like a grafity would be, in the wall of a house on the outside. In México “Grutas de la virgen” are just like that.

This wayspot is available for walking access, anyone can walk and encounter it without any barrier.

There’s no reason to say it has no public acess.

  1. Counter arguments
    Theres a little “pestaña” that’s the way in which in spanish we call the “parking gate”
    If you click on street view you would see it. But theres a catch. Clarification: this parking gate is open from 07h00 to 00h00. For security it is closed from 01h00 to 06h00.

  2. Discussion and Conclusion
    Saying the parking gate implies no public access is like saying private urbanizations (GATED COMUNITIES) in guayaquil that have their miny cities closed to public and only residents can enter should not have Waystops. In reality they do and they have a lot, because people of their private comunity see those waystops.

The parking gate is little and allows walking even in the time of 01h00 to 06h00.

Also, there’s plenty of places that are closed at night and still can we waystops.

This nomination has what it needs to guarantee public access at all times, it’s outside private property and has significance to the comunity that cherishes it as the only image of the “Virgen” on that street. Therefore I request your help and assistance to clarify this topic. Thank you for your attention.

It looks like the staff member has determined that the wall it is on belongs to a single family private home.

If that is accurate, then it doesn’t matter how accessible the object is, the location is ineligible.

This would apply to anything in such a location, including street signs (not that those are usually eligible anyway), little free libraries, shrines, murals, etc.

If you have solid evidence that the wall is not the outer boundary of a private house, then that may help your case, but it appears that you know that it is, as you’ve said:

Please have a look at Private Residences, Farmland & K-12, which clarifies the issue around Private Property and what this means for wayfarer.