Rethinking Fire Trails under Safety Guidelines & Emergency Services Access

Good morning / afternoon lovely community members,

I would love to open up a discussion regarding fire trails and how they fit into current Wayfarer criteria, specifically looking at how they conflict with Safe Pedestrian Access and the rules against Obstructing Emergency Services.

As a volunteer firefighter of nearly 10 years, I fully support the strict ineligibility rules surrounding emergency service access. However, I believe official fire trails present the exact same operational hazards, and I want to share my concerns from a first-responder perspective.

I’ve spent a decade in the field and have been on over 100+ fire trails. Based on that experience, I see two primary issues when these are approved, creating a direct conflict with core safety criteria:

  1. Obstruction of Emergency Services Access & Operational Danger.
    Fire trails are purpose-built infrastructure designed strictly for heavy fire apparatus to access active blazes. When a crew is responding to a fire, our focus must be entirely on extreme heat, heavy smoke, fire behaviour, and crew safety. Introducing distracted pedestrians—who are looking at their phones—into an active emergency zone introduces an unnecessary and dangerous layer of risk. On a narrow trail with poor visibility, the absolute last thing a crew needs to worry about is a member of the public blocking the route, or worse, the tragic possibility of someone being hit by a heavy emergency vehicle.

  2. Failure to Meet Safe Pedestrian Access Guidelines.
    . While these routes use the word “trail,” they rarely function as safe, high-quality pathways for pedestrians. Over my years of service, I have observed several consistent hazards that fail Niantic’s pedestrian safety standards:

. Poor Maintenance & Ground Hazards: These trails are designed for rugged 4x4 vehicles, not public recreation. They are frequently blocked by heavy overgrowth, fallen trees, and hazardous, unmaintained terrain.

. Limited Egress (Trap Hazards): Fire trails often have very limited exit points. Wildfires create unpredictable weather and can shift in seconds. If community members are utilizing these trails during an incident, they risk becoming trapped. Instead of fighting the fire, emergency services are then forced to divert life-saving resources toward civilian rescue.

. Informal Routes: Many fire trails lack official naming, signage, or permanent pathways. First responders often need to clear debris or alter the path on the fly just to get through.

To put it into perspective: the only things you see on an active fire trail are emergency crews and wildlife running for their lives to find safety. If wildlife knows it isn’t a safe place to be, we should not be encouraging community members to gather there for a game.

Because these locations fundamentally lack safe pedestrian access and have the clear potential to obstruct emergency services during critical operations, I personally cannot approve them under the current guidelines.

I would love to hear how other reviewers approach fire trails and whether you feel the criteria should explicitly reject them based on these serious hazards.

Thanks,
Woodystar588

Hmm. We don’t call these “trails” here. They appear to be roads and should be ineligible.

Yup. I had never heard of them either (UK).

I agree that they are not eligible submissions (as they don’t meet any of the criteria), but I don’t think that they are necessarily ineligible on the grounds of fire service access.

Anywhere that could conceivably catch fire has the potential to be a location that the fire service may need access to, and you have to trust players with a small amount of common sense if their immediate vicinity is on fire. Sure, these spaces are known for wildfires and it’s considerably more likely, but they aren’t specifically the FS’ base of operations on a regular basis.

In any case, it’s a bit pointless going into the semantics, as I already think that they don’t meet criteria :smiley:

Exactly, Thank you for the support on this.

That is the exact issue we face here in Australia. Because they have the word “trail” in the name, reviewers often look at a map, see the word “trail,” and blindly approve them as if they are standard recreational walking tracks.

In reality, as you just pointed out, they are strictly unpaved utility/emergency roads. They lack the pedestrian infrastructure required for a safe Wayspot and are built entirely for heavy machinery and fire truck access.

Hopefully, more reviewers will start looking past the word “trail” and realize that these are vital emergency transit routes that should be kept clear of distracted players.

Thanks for chiming in! I really appreciate the UK perspective, and I’m glad we agree that they don’t meet the core criteria anyway.

You make a fair point that technically anywhere can catch fire, and any location has the potential to “catch a lot” depending on the conditions. But the big difference with fire trails is that they are critical, narrow transit funnels with limited exits.

Unlike a park or an open field where people can easily move out of the way, a fire trail is often a single dirt track cut through dense bushland. If a player is walking on the track or blocks the gate when a crew is rushing in, there is literally nowhere for anyone to pull over.

The main reason I wanted to provide this information is so that if any Australian reviewers are reading this thread, they get the drift and stop approving them. Over here, bushfires move with terrifying speed, and our crews rely entirely on these routes to get in and out safely. I just wanted to shed some light from a firsthand perspective so our local review community understands the real-world risk!

I think that it would depend on context and that reviewers would need to apply their judgement for the particular nomination.

I don’t think it is black and white enough to make a nationwide judgement.

RFS has this document for use of fire trails which says:

During periods between No Rating or High fire danger ratings (AFDRS), fire trails may be used without any special precautions, apart from normal safe driving procedures.

In terms of specific fire trails…

When official government sources are recommending selected trails as great places to explore on foot or mountain bikes, this is a very different perspective.

Certainly in my area, when there is extreme fire danger, local national parks get closed to everyone. That is regardless of whether it is a fire trail or other walking trail in the park. People wouldn’t be walking the fire trail on their phones because the whole park would be closed.

As I said, I think it would depend on the submission and I would use my judgement based on whether it appears to be somewhere which is a good for hiking – based on provided supporting information – or whether it is a service utility only and not a good place for hiking. There would be some I would reject and there would be some that I don’t.

I suspect that this is heavily dependent on the trail. While that might be consistent with the many trails you have encountered, the examples listed above seem to be quite different.

Hi mate,

Thanks for providing that helpful context and those official examples! You’ve actually made me change my mind. After seeing those examples, I’ve realized I could have been reviewing them incorrectly.

I agree that if they are inside a native park forest or if they are an official council fire trail listed on a website, they could fit the criteria and be safe. They can absolutely be a good Wayspot—but only if the trail provides enough room for vehicles to be able to pass through safely if needed.

However, single-lane dirt firetrails are simply unsafe and shouldn’t be approved.

Thanks for your insight on this topic. My first-responder mind totally overlooked those types of official firetrails, and the fact that parks and gardens look after these areas in wildfires totally made me miss it all together

It is probably also of note is that a lot of Fire Trails in Australia cross private property, and the owner has an agreement for access with RFS/CFA/whichever fire service, and not the trail walkers.