Submission should be auto rejected if supporting photos is main photo cropped (or vice versa)

Generative AI is still not great for consistency so many of those fake submissions just use a cropped version as the main or supporting photo.

The rest if reviewers care it’s not that hard to spot something inconsistent and report.

I disagree. An honest submitter could have forgotten to take a supporting photo, or realized there was something in the supporting photo later that might look like an identifier so not wanted to use it. I don’t think that should be automatically rejected if the two photos are the same - but it should be a red flag for reviewers. Just like a completely unrelated supporting photo.

If there was a way to communicate that this is a red flag to reviewers that would be great, but there isn’t.

Personally, I have no issue with a different supporting photo being a mandatory requirement, especially now submitters can add five of them.

I’m sure we’ve all taken a main image snap and later realised it had a face or a numberplate in a reflection or similar. It’s always slightly disappointing, but the solution is to go take another picture, or to switch to a different one you already took. Same should apply to supporting images.

Take five, then you can weed one or two out if you need to.

Might be worth noting that the guidance says:

For supporting photographs, submit a photo that includes the object. The photo should allow the reviewers to confirm the location of the object by the surrounding recognizable features that can be spotted on satellite view or similar.

While this doesn’t say “and reviewers ought to reject if this isn’t the case”, submitters cannot say that the information isn’t out there.

I can’t tell from your reply to me. Do you agree with the topic post?

Yes.

If the fuller version shows the point of interest in place and the cropped photo focuses on the object, then this guideline has been fulfilled. If the same photo does both, then this guideline has been fulfilled. And please note the word “should” used here.

Yeah I agree with Cyndie. One time my main photo accidentally captured the floor instead of the bust I was trying to nominate so I had to use a crop of the supporting photo as my main. Also, I mostly submit square photos as main so sometimes I include the uncropped version as one of the supporting photos if it gives a little bit more context.

I think a good compromise could be to reject if the main photo and only supporting are exactly the same, BUT it would be better to teach ML how to check for SynthID since that would be a better way to automatically reject AI generated submissions.

To use an AI picture checking system for commercial purposes presumably comes with a moderate price tag.

Unless ML can check for the Synth ID itself (and I have no idea if that’s a thing or not), I can’t see this happening.