Auto-rejection

After the new wayfarer site update, i’m not sure if the AI got changed or anything in the system did, but for the first time ever, 2 of my submissions back to back got auto rejected before ever even making it into reviewing. One was rejected simply for “not meeting wayfarer criteria”. Not at all sure what this was about, so I appealed. It was accepted. Right after this, another submission was denied for being a duplicate. There were 2 brand new footbridges built on a trail system in my town. Both of which are distinct and separate, although they have the same architect. This does not constitute a duplicate. In fact, the photos AND supporting photos of the wayspot submissions clearly showed the second bridge in the background. I cleared up confusion for the reviewers in the supporting information. Linked the official city instagram page post on the grand reopening of this trail system that was brought about by the construction of these bridges, and properly marked them as distinct by their difference in geographic location, in size (one being 40 foot and one being 60 foot long) and their uniqueness to the obstacles they tackled for the pedestrian. I appealed, it was of course accepted as it could NOT have been more clear this was a separate footbridge along the trail. IT WAS IN THE
SUPPORTING PHOTOS THEMSELVES THAT THERE WERE TWO. BOTH S FOR THAT MATTER. So all fine and dandy, just a tad annoying, right? Wrong. So because wayfarer has tagged 2 of my submissions for auto denial, and I used my appeals, I now no longer have any appeals for 21 days. So you’re telling me, when YOUR system wrongly auto-rejects something I spent an hour working on to make sure there was no confusion and it couldn’t possibly be denied for being a duplicate, that I am now punished and have to wait 3 weeks to restore an appeal that I never should have had to use? Are you joking? This is absurd. I wouldn’t be appealing if it wasn’t obvious. If there was any ambiguity or I was towing the line, I’d hold the rejection fair and square. MAYBE i’d resubmit and frame it another way. Not to mention I had no idea I only had 2 appeals, as this is my first time ever getting rejected and using them. (I only have had one rejection on a memorial bench for a vietnam pilot, city councilman and alderman, all of which was linked in the supporting info but reviewers are apparently incompetent and woefully unpatriotic. Couldn’t have chosen someone more pertinent to their community than a vietnam war veteran who then served his community for the rest of his life. But sure, I digress.) I never appealed that nomination as it was when I first started out, and I was sure I could find more information to link so people wouldn’t be such sticklers on a memorial bench about a VIETNAM VETERAN. So to summarize, YOUR system auto-rejects on what criterion? And why is there no compensation for my appeal when it is YOUR fault. Like I said, if there was ambiguity, I’d understand. It couldn’t be more obvious who’s fault this is. So now I have to wait for these appeals to restore. Why? Fix your automated system, and fix this appeals nonsense. Please. There is no reason for the people who do the job FOR YOU on mapping the world to be punished because YOUR system wrongfully flags stuff. Fix the appeals limit. Please. Even if it’s like an american football challenge system. As long as you win that challenge, you don’t lose it. If you don’t it’s gone.

The waiting period for appeals to refresh is 15 days now.

(Not dismissing your post, just wanted to address that.)

You aren’t being punished at all. We are allowed to make suggestions for improving a map that belongs to Scopely. Those suggestions have to follow a process and one of the hurdles is a machine learning tool that filters out an absolute ton of crap submissions, but sometimes also catches a good one.

The alternative is that all those crap subs flood the system, and we go back to the voting process taking months, or even years as it was at one point.

Just as an aside, I had to skim-read your post, as the single block of text with sections of caps is very difficult to read on a screen.

That is definitely an improvement, NOT what it should be, but an improvement nonetheless. Thanks very much for that information, I had no idea.

It quite literally is a punishment to delay ME as a player by withholding MY contributions that I contributed BECAUSE they benefited ME and MY community. As for you not liking me typing a paragraph. Womp Womp. I didn’t submit this wayspot because it benefits scopely, or because I get paid to benefit scopely. I submitted it for a reason. That reason is I get use out of it. Hence why they have the system they do. Are you tracking this yet? That was the whole point of one of the games. YOU get to catch little monsters, THEY map the world. A relationship where we think we are being benefited, so we entertain it and do the work for them. Less wayspots = not as efficient, and people are less likely to play and keep playing. Not a single thing of what you just commented in your nasty tone was helpful. Like.. at all? I’m sorry that you don’t yet comprehend the trade off and what these games are doing. What they do for you is nothing compared to what you do for them. So once again, yes. It is a punishment. We make suggestions on the map to benefit us, not them. If it was just for them, we’d be getting paid to do it. Thanks sooooo much for this input!

Just an aside, I have never seen this level of corporation defense, it was very difficult to read on a screen. To act like I should be thankful for a messed up system because it COULD be worse is hysterical. Thanks!!!

Hello and welcome @kmoneykj
First if have any issues with a post users can flag the post and the Wayfarer Team will review.
Clicking on the … beneath a post brings up the flag option

Otherwise the expectation is that all wayfinders are respectful to each other. It is perfectly possible to disagree in a civilised way.

It is frustrating when we get rejections especially if it is an auto rejection. By its very nature it’s hard to discern why one submission is rejected and a similar one is not. And not being able to give a straight answer does not help to progress matters.

The key issue that this forum can assist with is offering impartial advice based on experience of what might be happening. The community can make suggestions to try and improve so that the end goal of getting a wayspot, and subsequently something to play with in the game can happen.

This article lays out ideas round working through the rejections -it may be helpful.

If you would like help then sharing the full nomination is what we need to see. We can then make suggestions, and work with you to try and improve the submission.

If people can’t read your posts because it is a wall of text, and they take the trouble to tell you this, attacking them for that is pointless. Your wall of text is the problem, not the readers.

You are not being personally punished.

For what it’s worth, two similar bridges close together can legitimately be described as not distinct and as duplicates of each other. Just as with playground equipment, individual objects can represent a wider area.

This was definitely true when Pokemon Go / Wayfarer was owned by Niantic.

Niantic was a Mapping / AI company that created the games to assist in this.

Scopely is a mobile game company so the Mapping part is not as big an issue as it used to be.

Agree that no movement in the map could make the game feel stale but allowing anything to flood the map with Coal would also be bad for the game. Not everyone believes “More Stops = Better Game”.

  1. I didn’t put this post under this thread. Someone moved it from bug reports to this. I don’t need help with the submission. The submission was perfect, hence why it got accepted when i appealed. This is a report about the auto denial system. NOT about being rejected. but if you want to see the submission, sure


  2. I disagreed the same way the person disagreed with ME. I was very civilized, in fact I used the same exact language the person used when disagreeing with me. If i’m wrong then so are they.

  3. Once again, the appeal was accepted, i didn’t need help with the submission, appealing, or resubmitting or anything, which is why i’m really not sure why my post was moved to this thread. My whole point is don’t auto reject an obviously good submission, it occurred on the day of the new website layout update, so I figured it was a bug to be happening to multiple things of mine.

I didn’t argue to let trash into the game, i’m against it. I think it makes it less fun. My point is to not auto reject good submissions and to fix the system. Hence why this was posted in bug reports to begin with, but it was moved to a different thread by some administrator or moderator. I figured with this happening more than twice it was obviously an issue. After 3 times it’s a pattern not a coincidence. Bug Report and asking for them to fix the appeals system. That was the point.

Your submission was not perfect. No submission is perfect.

For example, your photo has far too much meaningless foreground. Half the photo is meaningless indistinct foreground. I can immediately see why this would be rejected by an ML filter and what you could have done to improve this submission.

Next time you get a rejection, look at your submission to see how it could be improved. Thinking every time “my submission is perfect” is not how to improve.

There’s nothing to fix. This was not a bug but a reasonable auto-rejection.

Nobody attacked anybody bud. I’m sorry you felt offended. Anyways, it wasn’t quite meant for some random person to give me feedback on what they think of my text. It was a bug report for a scopely worker to read because of the fact that multiple submissions on the date of the new update got auto rejected immediately. I did my best to give details, i didn’t intend on brevity at all. I respectfully, truthfully, could not care less if someone who can’t help my situation doesn’t like the details and how i laid them out. It wasn’t meant for them to give input on. It was for moderators to know there’s an issue with the AI, not for a member of the community to offer no help and instead attack MY post. If you can’t read it then.. don’t? I don’t know what else to say bud. It really sounds like a personal problem. Thanks for your input nonetheless champ! :grin:

Ohh, it was reasonable. That’s why the appeal got accepted! Thanks so much for your input once again, someone will totally take it into consideration! Thanks!

You can click on the pencil to see who did the edit. Scopely staff did read it.

Maybe next time I’ll remember that the forum shows who edited the tag. I had forgotten so thanks for the heads-up :slight_smile:

I’m unsure of why you’re not getting the point. I don’t care to have you interact with my post anymore. Please, leave me alone and quit replying to me trying to message me.

Mod Edit: Removed the part that violated the Forum guidelines.

Thank you, I am aware of did the edit. But that doesn’t help me and is kind of irrelevant. I’m just unsure of why.

if you feel a post is inappropriate, including mine, you can flag it for staff instead of continuing the conversation on the topic (and often derailing it.)

expand the three dots and you will see the flag option there.
image
image

Hey @kmoneykj ,

Welcome to the Wayfarer Community Forum.

There has been no change to the ML models we use.

We are unable to provide specific details for each nomination that is ineligible in this thread. If you feel that your rejected nomination should have been approved, you can now appeal it. To appeal a rejected nomination, please follow these steps:

  1. Log in to Wayfarer
  2. Go to your Submit page: Scopely Explore Wayfarer
  3. Click the nomination you’d like to submit an appeal for
  4. Click the Appeal button and enter a note on why this nomination should be accepted.
  5. Click Submit nomination.

Note you can submit only two appeals per 15 days. If you have already submitted an appeal, you may see an error when you try to appeal another nomination.

Alternatively, we suggest re-submitting the Wayspot candidate after improving the title, description, and/or photo. Also, feel free to discuss your nomination with other players. Our community is great at suggesting improvements to nominations.

We understand that the Wayfarer system can render decisions that you disagree with. This is why we have appeals. We have increased the frequency of appeals whenever possible.

It evaluates the nomination as a whole and makes a decision.

Thanks,