Here is my problem
I have gone thru various Cabins and Points of Interest at my Family Camp Ground and some of them Passed and were accepted, while others were Rejected. Despite my efforts to provide good data and Descriptions. I appealed One of them and the Appeal Reviewer said it was a common structure. With no further Guidance… Thanks…
No Good - Hate to Quit It Cabin
Good - Wanaki Cabin
What should I do next?
These Named Cabins (and other Camp Structures) are the main Features of this Campground, each with there own Charm.
These Cabins were built in the 1940s, and are the Places for new people to come and stay at the campground, and EXPLORE Camp Wellville.
Should I Re Nominate the Same Cabins, but with more in Depth Descriptions?
Like little facts, about these places?
Or is there away to over turn Appeals?
Edit: Any tips for making these Cabins and stuff better nominations?
I’m not a writer, (I am a Photographer) but if i have to add more to the Descriptions to make it work, I will.
Welcome to the forum!
There is no pathway to appeal an appeal decision. Occasionally, with overwhelming evidence that the appeal decision was clearly wrong, a new email will quietly be received after posting on the forum with a different decision.
Personally, I would reject this if it is intended for a family to rent out. That would fall under SFPRP for me.
The appeals team reason also makes sense if you did not provide any reason why this would be worthy of exploration. A place you can stay at the camp is not the same as a destination to seek out. I would think that the camp would be worthy of exploration, but not all the individual cabins.
I really dislike flowery AI text, and find simple text refreshing. So more is not always better. But it does need to tell me why I would want to seek this out specifically. So resubmitting with a bit more info as to why someone would want to visit this cabin could work.
What does SFPRP mean/stand for?
Single Family Private Residential Property - if a family is expected to live there even temporarily, I would consider that off limits.
There is a glossary of common terms we use here: Glossary for Common Wayfarer Terms
But it says PRP instead of SFPRP
Thanks for the Link!
I read the whole Page.
That considered, Based on my Question, other than a more detailed description any other tips for Submitting?
Since it seems it wasn’t the description that got the submissions rejected.
Are there certain things that show up in the photo that make it inelegible?
It was the most bland (Least exciting) Cabin that was accepted after all…
I don’t think either cabin should be accepted due to it being home-based property for a single family (at a time). I would also reject for SFPRP, which you cannot get past with a better photo.
Not so sure about the SFPRP, as these are not places where people live, just where they stay during holidays (from a legal standpoint there is huge difference, from a legal standpoint I would consider these commercial property)
However I would reject them for non-distinct, as I don’t consider them a POI.
