Incorrect Duplicate Rejection

Hi,

im looking for some help in regards to a recent staff appeal decision that incorrectly marked my nomination as a duplicate.

My nomination is an amphiteather style seating and was rejected as a duplicate. However, this feature is a completely distinct object in the park complex. In this park complex there is the actual grass field, a meeting area which has a few sandstone blocks, wooden poles and then a steel arbour structure over it and then the amphiteather style seating seating.

I was wondering if I could get a second opinion on this decision.
Thanks

(If anyone wants to read this is what I had in the description/supporting information of the actual submission:
This is in a gated community, however, according to wayfarer guidelines, gated communities are allowed. This submission meets many of the criteria as it is a great place to be social with others and is permanent and distinct. There is space for individuals to place their feet when sitting on the blocks as there is a gap between the blocks and plants/grass infront of it. It is separate to the steel arbor structure on the opposite side of the field, and is separate to the actual field. The amphiteather lies within safe pedestrian access and not on a private single family property. Even though private backyard fences can be seen in some of the pictures, it is fully separated as the homeowners are not able to enter the amphitheater seating directly from their backyard.)


the bottom wayspot is the arbour structure meeting area and the right one is for the grass field

Do you know which wayspot the amphitheatre style seating was marked as a duplicate of? What photo did you use?

I notice that the two existing wayspots share a photo, suggesting that “The Point Field” was marked as a duplicate when it was first submitted, then resubmitted (successfully) with the same photo.

So to be clear, there is an existing spot for a curved stone seating structure that sits at the edge of a large green space, and your nomination is distinct because it’s at the other end of the green space?

I may be being unfair because of the lack of imagery (no StreetView etc.), but on the face of it, I would also have marked this as a duplicate. It all seems to be part of the general ‘amphitheatre’ area.

It might also be worth noting that this area is completely filled in terms of waypoints that will become pokestops, just in case that makes a difference as to how much effort you wish to put into this.

I actually disagree - the second photo on the “The Point community meeting and social area” wayspot clearly shows there is a social area at the bottom left which is distinct from the amphitheatre style seating, which I do think is a separate POI.


this is the steel arbor structure/meeting spot that has some stones for sitting

powerspot? :eyes:
(idk how they work but maybe it could be one)

I would never consider amphitheater seating as separately significant. That’s like the bleachers at a ball field.

Fair enough, as I said, I might be being unfair!

If OP were to share the photo and supporting photos, I could very well change my mind – not that it’s me they need to convince! :smiley:

That’s the one already in game, right?

yes the picture with the steel arbor structure with the wooden poles and like a few stones is the one in game. Could it be possible that the staff who reviewed it saw"The point field" at the start of the amphiteather submission (Which was called “The Point Field Tiered Amphitheater Seating”) and instantly thought it was the same as “The point field”

Amphitheatre seating just strikes me differently to bleachers. I think it is inherently valuable, probably because of the link back to the ancient structures in Italy. I can imagine sitting on these for social reasons without anything happening on the field itself, making them a specific destination, but regular stands at a sports ground just don’t have the same appeal.

How did you argue that this seating at the field meets any of the criteria of a great place for exercise, exploration, or being social in a way that is distinct from the field?

Disagree strongly. The amphitheater seating IS the amphitheater. The seating IS the field.

For me it’s the metal structure that makes any of this seating interesting enough to meet exploration criteria.

Maybe it could meet social if it’s feasible to call it a picnic spot, but there’s no evidence that it is used like an amphitheatre is actually used.

I’m happy to disagree :slight_smile:

This just seems to address that it is there. I don’t see where you have conveyed how this meets any of the eligibility requirements of a great place to exercise, explore, or be social.

I agree with the appeals team that this is just part of the existing field from what I see here.

“A favorite gathering place for friends or strangers alike, where you can share a drink or meal, be entertained, or watch public life happen.”
Amphiteather seating is specifically designed to go around the field so you can sit and watch whats happening on the field (be entertained/watch public life happen).

If you only go there to watch what’s happening on the field, then it is hard to distinguish it from the field itself, regardless of what I said above.