I reported this wayspot and it was rejected when all of the photos are ineligible.
40.758739, -73.985190
All 37 photos include an identifiable face. Except for two, one taken and cropped straight from Wikipedia and the other blurry, low pixelated and doesn’t have the lighting settings well.
You want them to remove Times Square as Wayspot? This is an iconic landmark that is definitely eligible. Are you trying to get a gym to populate somewhere else?
You can report the Wikipedia photo for removal from the Wayspot photos through help chat which appears to be on there twice. There is a tilted photo they might also remove, but I don’t see any others that definitely meet removal criteria. I even love the example you show there as “low quality” for capturing the experience of ringing in the New Year.
The rule is not that photos cannot include people. It is that they cannot be the focus of the photo.
It is not good practice to present a screenshot out of context.
This is the link to the post:
If you don’t agree with the point that has been made in a post it is better to simply state why your view differs in this case. Keep it to the points of information rather than the person.
I linked the post already so no I did not leave out context you can see all the context in this post and the comment they supported. From this post they stated this:
”The rule is not that photos cannot include people. It is that they cannot be the focus of the photo” when I said you can see an identifiable face on every photo except some where you can see license plates, are from Wikipedia and so on all ineligible.
This is the comment that the fellow wayfinder made they simply thought the previous statement was worth noting overall.
A reaction is different from actually saying something.
I have provided the route to refer the photos to the team for them to review.
So that is all you need to do.
I get your disgruntled from you own wayspot getting rejected. But reporting time squares wayspot for ineligible photos for a “gotcha moment” isn’t really going to prove anything. Unfortunately wayfarer is pretty fluid and a lot of things are up to best judgment. There are some photos that could be removed with people front and center but most pictures are fine.
For what it’s worth I don’t think your submission should have been rejected for the people in the bottom left. And unfortunately scopely likes to remain pretty neutral during appeals in my experience. So even if the you can barely see people in your picture they are just going to stick with the original ruling since there are in fact people in the picture. That’s just the nature of wayfarer and we have all been through bad rejections before.
I do not understand the point you are trying to make. I didn’t see any recognizable faces in those photos, either. If you did, you can report those, too. Through help chat, as @elijustrying explained.
OP is saying “Why was my image an issue, when the photos from the Times Square waypoint contain far more obvious images of people”.
While this is a hilariously silly way to make that point, there is a point.
(I think I still stand by my previous point: ‘Yeah, I guess the rules do technically say that, but if they aren’t really recognisable, and definitely aren’t the subject of the image, it’s fine from a legal standpoint, so why should anyone care?’)
More seriously, we are somewhat comparing apples and oranges.
In one case we have a submission being rejected because there were people in the picture.
In the other case, we have staff refusing to remove an existing waypoint because the photo includes people.
So one managed to get past reviewers and one did not. That happens. Reviewers make mistakes, and sometimes you get a bunch of stricter ones, and sometimes a bunch who are accepting everything.
There is then the difference between rejecting something at submission stage and removing something after it has been accepted by reviewers. Staff are happy to do the former during appeals, but require greater reason to do the latter – this is the gap between rejection and removal criteria, and it provides a small cushion for the grey area of ‘reviewers’ opinions’.