This is far easier with the coordinates, but I understand your reticence.
This might sound rude, but this ‘issue’ almost always turns out to be due to some kind of user error.
So, first question:
What method of seeing cells are you using? If IITC, bear in mind that this is now 18 months out of date, and waypoints may have been moved over cell lines in the meantime.
Just my two cents: I’ve personally never seen this happen unless there just isn’t a sync for a whole week. Countless times, whenever one of my submissions was approved that would cause a new gym to spawn according to known observations by the global community, that gym would pop up as soon as the next sync happens, which is usually within 24 hours.
In addition to the other suggestions made, other possibilities for a gym not being promoted as expected can be from using a source like pogomaps which can have wayspot placement and even cell line placement incorrect, or not taking into account sponsored locations. Also, if Wayspots have been location edited, it can take longer for the system to recognize them at their new locations.
Staff will tell you if there are any issues with the Wayspots, but they will not address the community observations on gym promotion.
We do not vouch for the authenticity of information found on third party sites and platforms.
I have looked into your submission and the details provided here. I believe I have located the location in question.
There are no issues with density and inclusion rules at this location.
After a nomination is approved by reviewers, there is an additional automated review that determines whether the nomination is an appropriate fit for each particular Scopely Explore game. Each game has their own set of criteria for this step.
This same automated review determines whether a submission should become a PokéStop or a Gym. This process is completely automated and free of any manual control.
I appreciate that you do not wish to share your location, but if you could confirm what method / map / website you are using to see the cells, that might go some way to working out what the issue is here.
I suspect this is a map provided by a third party. After double-checking all the coordinates, it appears to be “5.” Please be cautious, as using map-related tools can lead to your account being revoked. It would be ideal if you had a knowledgeable friend nearby.
Staff will not discuss S2 cells. You don’t want to share the location with us. We are not allowed to share links to a third party tool that is accurate so that you can check yourself. You may be able to find this tool yourself by searching for wayfarer tools on the internet.
Staff do tell you if there are any issues with a location, so if Aaron says there is nothing wrong there, there is nothing wrong there.