Im genuinely confused. A few weeks ago i went to this same exact forum to ask for information about the eligibility of directional trail markers painted in things such as trees, rocks and posts, and according to you guys it should be accepted. But recently, i’ve submitted 6 of these markers and 2 of them already were rejected for being “temporary or different”. I don’t think they should be rejected since theyre permanent because they’re a part of an official trail network in my city, but who knows.
I’ll be leaving the info that i used for the wayspot below.
This should be eligible but the painted markers are sometimes rejected by the community. Maybe they also rejected this specific one since the x technically means “wrong direction/trail doesn’t pass continue this way”
Forget the “not this way” signs and concentrate on the actual trail markers.
Resubmit and appeal only if you keep getting rejected.
Since you find these hard to get accepted, I would create multiple submissions and put the rest on hold - doing this once is quicker than doing them one at a time later.
Just appeal it that’s what I do if I get rejected there’s a lot of picky people that vote and take it way too serious.
I appealed for another one of these recently and it got accepted, bringing a new gym to a neighbourhood nearby. Now im out of appeals, but oh well
gotta wait till November i guess
You don’t have to wait until you can appeal. You can make a new submission. Maybe now that a couple are live on the map people will read your supporting section offering proof that these are the official markers. Maybe, not, but it doesn’t hurt anything to try again.
Well i DID try with markers from another trail that was right next to this one, it had over 14 markers approved and got rejected for the same funny reason. But i guess i can try again
Sometimes you can use the additional text to point out that other, similar markers have been accepted. Whether reviewers pay any attention is another matter.
Yeah i could certainly try that! They probably wont read my whole thing since it has over 800 letters. So i’ll make sure to put it more in the beginning
Sometimes with Wayfarer, less is more. If you give people too much to read they are more likely to skip/find a reason to reject. It’s a fine balance to strike
I don’t have a good example to show you how I would submit this kind of trail marker. I would give each one a distinct name, based on location. I would have a short and simple description. Maybe explain here what the yellow and red stripe indicate. In the supporting text section, I would write a very short message, maybe “Official markers for exploring this trail. See: ”. For supporting photos, try to see if there is anything that you can include in the photo with the marker that a reviewer might be able to locate on Maps to feel good about the location.
Alright, got it!
I’ll see what i can do ![]()
Most of it seems doablez the hardest part would be finding places that are findable via satellite, since the area doesnt have street view and theres not much stuff nearby since the trail only has a few abandoned housed and other abandoned stuff along the way
It does not have to have something visible on satellite view. That is just something to look around for if it is there that can help. Not a requirement.
Oooooh i think i get what you mean. So like just in case that theres something like an old building or other stuff to help the others to feel more safe about the location that i put
My normal format is something like this:
Title:
[Name of trail in shorthand] Trail Marker – [Road Name] [/ Other Road Name (if near a junction)]*
Description:
Part of a [length of trail] trail known as “[a nice description of the trail you found somewhere – official if possible]”, this marker is located at the [description of a local landmark, or failing that, a description of what the trail is doing, such as “at the point the trail turns south towards Green Park”]
Additional text:
Exercise criteria. This is part of an established trail that passes [scope of trail (e.g. “from A to B”, or “in a circle around the south of TOWN”)]. [Visible / not visible] on StreetView**, and a map (or other confirmation it exists) can be found at [website link].
*The last part of the name should be unique from the other markers, but try not to get bogged down in numerical codes for the markers. I’ve been known to use “Smith Street East, Smith Street Central, Smith Street West” or similar.
**If not visible on StreetView, I usually put a short sentence about how one of the supporting images somehow confirms the location, whether that’s a landmark in the background or the shape of the visible path.
I don’t think this is a fair comment.
There are a lot wayfinders who vote correctly to reject submissions that do not meet acceptance criteria is more accurate.
Thank you so much for everyone’s help. Today, after coming back from the same trail and collecting over 13 drafts for the future, i recieved an email from wayfarer indicating that one of the trail markers was accepted! (Its from a trail that connects with this one)
Thank you to everyone that helped me through this process, and im looking forward to submitting more
See yall in my next doubt,
-DavidiMoralis





